Modern Life is Rubbish

“To be hopeful in bad times is not just foolishly romantic. It is based on the fact that human history is a history not only of cruelty, but also of compassion, sacrifice, courage and kindness… The future is an infinite succession of presents, and to live now as we think human beings should live, in defiance of all that is bad around us, is itself a marvelous victory.” ~ Howard Zinn.
Showing posts with label u2. Show all posts
Showing posts with label u2. Show all posts

Monday, March 15, 2010

u2 ~ The Unforgettable Fire

Finally, i got my hands on my favourite music album of the 80's-u2's 'The Unforgettable Fire' remastered album. And what kind of music is showcased on this album? Well, it's rock music but with a heavy touch of ambience (read: keyboards and synths, and reverbs) to create an atmospheric soundscape of experimental music. It is not ambient music but it's also not the usual classic rock music.

This album is different, both in sound and production, from their previous three. It is recorded in Slane Castle and Windmill Lane studio, Ireland. And they had Brian Eno and Daniel Lanois as producers and engineers for the first time. Whilst their first three albums, namely 'Boy', 'October' and 'War' were mainly out-and-out post-punk, stadium rock, this one is very different.

It's a one-off thing in terms of their musical sound as they would not repeat this sound ever again. There's a sense of atmosphere and space in the sound that is not found in other rock records of the time. Their next album, the one which established them as a mainstream rock act, 'The Joshua Tree' continues the 'spacey', wide-vista guitar sound to an extent but is heavily influenced by American blues and rock n'roll.

Why the 'remastered' album since i already have the original album? Well, the sound of the original 1984 album, in CD format, is not something to shout about. If i remembered right, an article in an audio magazine (forgot the name) mentioned that producer Brian Eno said the album was mixed for playing on a 'boom-box', since most people play music using that equipment at the time. This is from memory, so i could be mistaken. The cd sound it produced was 'tinny' with a narrow dynamic range, lo-fi so to speak, that doesn't do the music justice. But the music on the album is a different thing altogether. Until today, it still sounded timeless. Although the band and to an extent Bono himself had grand ambition for themselves during its release, it is truly a work of art. Experimental in its approach and sound, not the commercial fodder that so many of us (mis)took for music and art these days. These days, their album's name is too long while the music itself usually fall short of expectation.

Not trying to write a review of the album as so many has been written on this already. But a track by track articulations of the album is justified since this is one album that i really loved and which makes me take a step to change my life many years ago.

The album opens with 'A Sort of Homecoming'. It is one of their most emotionally affecting song and a great album opener. More so than "Where The Streets Have No Name" from 'The Joshua Tree'. Larry Mullen's drum on this track is most fascinating. Eschewing the straight-forward rock drum patterns on the other albums, it richochets and swirls with ianteresting variations. i could listen to the drums alone and still find it fascinating each time. Together with Edge's guitar which give the song, and the whole album in particular, its atmospheric feel, this song is certainly the highlight. Only one word- brilliant.

'Pride (In the name of love)' is one of their biggest single. The most straight-ahead rock piece, it has that sing-along, stadium rock feel and a good video. Incidentally, this is the first song which introduced them to me way back in my schooldays. i remembered not liking this one because it's so 'loud' and it's a rock song. Preferring the ear-friendly 'new wave' of Duran Duran and Culture Club.

Moving on to 'Wire'. Fast, with a passionate energy. Ambient guitar intro which seems to suggest space but then the drums and bass kicks in. The sound is dense and suffocating with the guitar providing the breathing 'space' as it moved along like a speeding train. A short and dizzying ride.

And then, the title track 'The Unforgettable Fire'. No other albums they made since then and before has "atmosphere" written over them. The sound that permeates the air before the song proper is what makes them 'magical'. And it's more evidently so in this song. This is the reason they brought in Eno and Lanois. The keyboards are just beautiful and the drums and guitars, instead of driving the song, only adds to the musical textures. It's apparent a lot of thought is put into its creation. To create something out of nothing takes time and effort. A lovely song and 'lovely' is not something that usually describe a rock song. Brilliant.

'Promenade'. Another lovely song. Not only the song but the words itself. With guitar sounding like keyboards. "Up the spiral staircase to a higher ground". Sometimes, it does feel like it. The short instrumental '4th of July' follows. Nothing much to say about this except as an intro to the second act perhaps. They never put an instrumental in any of their albums, before and after. Perhaps, this only served as an experimental side to this work.

Their most-played song on their live-set, 'Bad' is one of the longest song here. This slow-build, social commentary about heroin abuse does not quite 'work', at least for me. Bono's vocal is in great form on this, though. Next up is 'Indian Summer Sky'. The guitar, some parts driving but mostly used sparingly, like lightning flashes, that lends it a sense of foreboding gloom amidst the tight rhythm of Adam Clayton's bassline. The "hup hup" vocal parts gives the song an urgent feel somehow.

While 'Elvis Presley And America' with its semi-mumbling vocals and indiscernible chorus is hard to listen to for someone who had grown up listening mostly to commercial rock and pop melodies, the track itself is fascinating because of that. The rhythmic pattern is hypnotic on repeated listen. The closer, 'MLK' is a lullaby. And it's a beautiful, emotionally affecting one. They never close an album on a lullaby ever again.

No, it's not a perfect album. That is not important. Perfection doesn't exist in this world. This could be a pop album. They could sing country or perhaps add in some jazz. No, genre is not important too. It's the striving for perfection that makes this a musical work of art. It's also the reason the same could not be said of their later works.

"Burning hearts with limited tools made for a family practice. The usual tug of war-experimental music at one end of the rope and pop song at the other end-kept us up many late nights" ~ Daniel Lanois.

Poetry in music. It is the sonic equivalent of motion blur perceived by our sense of sight.

That just about sums up this experiment in music and art.

And finally, a short description of the sound quality. Is the remaster better than the original recording? Yes it is. Aside from a higher level of sound, it has more clarity than the 'muddy', low-fidelity sound of the 1989 master. The drums are distinct with more 'punch', and bass is deeper. Guitars sounds brighter, especially those short, atmospheric chiming parts. The texture of the songs could be felt as it's meant to be. Overall, the remastered version is a marked improvement without compromising on quality by being overly compressed.
The Unforgettable Fire (original 1984 master)

The Unforgettable Fire (2009 remaster)
As the simple diagram above show, the remastered version has a higher sound level. But the dynamic range relationship of the two mix (the difference between the softest and loudest sound that humans can perceived) are still maintained without clipping, as in so many of today's recording.

This album is not meant to be a lo-fi musical experience.

A review of the remastered album can be found in Pitchfork.

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Contentment on the horizon

Once a musician or group has achieved popularity or at least some sort of popularity and recognization, their music are considered mainstream.

The extremely popular group u2 started life as an underground punk group. Their music only appeal to certain small segment of listeners. Their early work, those seminal songs and albums from the 80's was still their best. Those who said their later or latest are their best either are too young to have listen to their earlier masterpieces or do not know how to differentiate between good and mediocre music.

As much as recent albums like "All That You Can't Leave Behind" and the last "How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb" had garnered positive and critical acclaim, at best they remain average albums on their own and mediocre compared to memorable gems like "The Unforgettable Fire", "The Joshua Tree", "Boy" and even "Achtung Baby".

Their upcoming "No Lines On The Horizon" has been getting good write-ups and preview even before the album is scheduled for worldwide release on March 2. Adjectives like "fantastically innovative", "some of their best work" and "sounds amazing" are now taken with a pinch of salt.

As a very old fan of the group from the 80's (yes, i'm that old), i had read the very favourable reviews of their last two albums- 'ATYCLB' and 'HTDAAB'. But frankly i found them a disappointment given the long time they spent in the studio making them. For the music they make which is rock music, they both are missing an important ingredient-passion. Good rock music requires fire and passion.

Also, their album's title seemed to get longer with every new release. Ego reflected in the titles?

So, it's not hard to tell i'm no longer so excited they're releasing a new album. Would of course get the album but the thrill of anticipation is no longer there. In fact, the feeling of disappointment is higher.

Hate to say it but maybe they have come close to 'sell-by dates'. Maybe age has to do with it. People tend to become mellower with age. Rock music is youths' music in spirit but when you get older the spirit tends to fizzle out (at least a little). Also, they tend to run out of things to say. Their lyric evokes the "haven't i heard this before" feeling more often than not.

Or maybe not. Maybe it's just that i'd heard all that they have to say. maybe it's just me getting older; too old for this kind of music. I'd grown to liked 'mellower' and more 'emotional' music through the years. Apart from 80's music (New Wave music), rock music is my singular favourite kind of music. From The Beatles to Led Zeppelin to Pink Floyd to U2 to Nirvana, used to lap up every kind of rock there were. But now, even Metallica and Guns N'Roses are not quite as appealing as previously. Heck, can't stand the high-pitched scream of Axl Rose the last time i listened to them.

Besides returning to new wave (or the much maligned 'retro') music and those 80's cantopop (from the likes of Alan Tam, Leslie Cheung, Jacky Cheung); Tsai Chin, Zhou Xuan, Ella Fitzgerald and Billie Holiday has slowly become my staples. Maybe i'm really getting old or worse, feeling it. Feeling old is definitely worse than getting old. You tend to lose interest in things which you once find enjoyable. Things which makes life worth living.

Just hope it's really the amazing, innovative and one of their best work after the last song had finished playing. In between now and then, there's still hope. But not too high a hope. Maybe it's time to move on but only for the memories. When music is put on a commercial pedestal in place of art and emotion, then it's not music anymore.